Show Notes
About the Guest
Dr. Destiny Huff, LPC, CPCS, is an Autistic and ADHD therapist, special education advocate, consultant, speaker, and parent of two neurodivergent children. Through Destiny Huff Consulting, she supports families and educators in creating neuroaffirming, inclusive, and accessible educational experiences for disabled and neurodivergent learners. Her work centers on connection over compliance, behavior as communication, student autonomy, intersectionality, and meaningful family participation in the IEP process. Drawing from professional expertise, lived experience, and parent advocacy, Dr. Huff helps communities move beyond deficit-based practices and toward environments where neurodivergent learners are understood, supported, and valued. She is the author of Neuroaffirming Advocacy: A Parent and Educator Guide to Special Education and co-hosts The Affirming Village Podcast with Lisa Baskin Wright.
Episode Summary
Destiny was already a mental health professional who had worked in schools when her oldest son started kindergarten in Louisiana. She asked early for a meeting, a behavior plan, an IEP. The answer was no. After winter break he was suspended three times in two weeks, sometimes less than an hour after arriving. A psychologist she called in tears asked, “What do you think about autism?” Her son was identified, and Destiny realized she was autistic too. The fallout reached the whole family: the Exceptional Family Member Program blocked an overseas move, her husband’s promotion stalled, and both of them changed careers so she could be available to her kids and their schools.
Destiny borrows a definition of neuroaffirming from her friend Cheryl Poe: to care. In practice that means asking whether we are supporting a child or trying to fix them, and including disabled kids in the support we design for them. She sees neuroaffirming going the way “inclusion” and “trauma-informed” did, slapped on things by people who can’t say what it looks like. On ABA, she doesn’t call for throwing everything out. She says the real problem is the compliance-based, deficit-based lens most professionals, herself included, were trained in, and that you have to question your own training to change it.
When people push back that schools need rules, Destiny asks why a teacher needs a student to do a particular thing. Often the answer is a schedule so packed there is no time to consider what the student needs. Kindergarten now teaches first grade content, and “30 minutes for lunch” is closer to 15. That is a systems issue. Inside the classroom, teachers already have room to move: keep the standards and let students show them through a slide deck, a comic strip, a video, a song, or a skit.
On placement, Destiny argues that sorting students by disability category is not neuroaffirming. Tim presses her on her own son, who ate lunch in his self-contained classroom because the cafeteria was too loud. Wouldn’t the most neuroaffirming move be to change the lunchroom? It turns out the school did. This year he eats with everybody else. Her closing advice for IEP teams is communication, collaboration, and documentation, and remembering that the parent is the only person who has been at every one of that child’s IEP meetings. The episode ends with Awake Among the Stars, our micro role-playing game adapted from Alone Among the Stars by Takuma Okada.
Read the transcript
Destiny Huff: In the beginning, you’re already assessing, where are my kids that are on target? Where are the kids that are below? Where are the kids that are above? And then you’re subsequently tailoring what you’re providing to that already. But the other side is I point out that I’ve never walked into a teacher’s classroom that looks the same as another teacher’s classroom.
Not ever. I don’t care if there’s a grade level theme. Your classroom is gonna look and be set up the way that makes you comfortable, and all we’re saying is, “How can I do that for my students?” We’re not having those conversations around the fact that the system is operating in a way that doesn’t allow for us to not be compliance-based. But then you do sometimes, depending on your program, your school, and your supervisor, have the opportunity to do that within your classroom. And I have seen educators that are like, “This is how I run my show.” And because of it, they have less, quote-unquote, “behavior issues.”
Tim Villegas: Hey, friends. Welcome back to Think Inclusive: Real Conversations About Building Schools Where Every Learner Belongs. I’m your host, Tim Villegas. Today, we’re talking about what neuroaffirming actually means in a school and what it has to do with where kids learn. My guest is Dr. Destiny Huff. Destiny is a licensed professional counselor, an autistic and ADHD therapist, a special education advocate, a consultant, a speaker, and the parent of two neurodivergent kids.
Through Destiny Huff Consulting, she works with families and educators to build neuroaffirming, inclusive, accessible schools for disabled and neurodivergent learners. Her work centers on connection over compliance, behavior as communication, student autonomy, and real family participation in the IEP process.
She’s the author of Neuroaffirming Advocacy, and she co-hosts The Affirming Village podcast with Lisa Baskin Wright. Destiny tells the story of her son’s kindergarten year, three suspensions in two weeks, and what it took to turn that around as a military family. We talk about compliance, ABA, and why the rules teachers ask for are often about the schedule, not the child. Then we get into placement.
Listen for the lunchroom. I push Destiny on whether the most neuroaffirming move is to change the lunchroom instead of pulling a kid out of it, and her answer is one of the best parts of the conversation. It’s what belonging looks like when a school actually adjusts.
Stick around after the interview because we are playing Awake Among the Stars, our micro role-playing game adapted from Alone Among the Stars by Takuma Okada. Link to the original game is in the show notes.
Before we meet our guest, I want to tell you about our sponsor. This episode is brought to you by IXL. IXL is an all-in-one platform for K-12 that helps boost student achievement, empowers teachers, and tracks progress in one place. As students practice, IXL adapts to their individual needs so that every learner gets just-right support and challenge, and each student gets a personalized learning plan to close gaps.
Check it out at ixl.com/inclusive. Again, that’s ixl.com/inclusive.
All right, after a quick break, it’s time to Think Inclusive with Dr. Destiny Huff. Catch you on the other side.
Dr. Destiny Huff, welcome to the Think Inclusive Podcast.
Destiny Huff: Hi, thank you for having me.
Tim Villegas: I am so glad you’re here. And before we started taping, I commented about your Snorlax in the background, and we are big Pokémon people in my family.
Destiny Huff: Yes, my son is the Pokémon Extraordinaire. And then he was like, “What do you guys know about Pokémon?”
And me and my husband were like, “What? We were around before you, sir. We know about Pokémon. What are you talking about?”
Tim Villegas: Yeah, exactly. I could talk about Pokémon the entire episode, but we’re not gonna do that because we’re here to talk about neuroaffirming advocacy.
And I just wanna mention at the top of this episode your book and resource, Neuroaffirming Advocacy: A Parent and Educator Guide to Special Education, which we will make sure to put in our show notes. So wonderful. So I’d like to start with a story that we’ve heard you tell about your son.
You are a licensed therapist with 15 years in the field, a certified trauma therapist for children, and when your oldest son started kindergarten, in Louisiana, I think, within just a few weeks, he had three suspensions. So I’d love for you to take us back there. What was the school telling you, and how did you approach that situation?
Destiny Huff: Yeah. I’ve worked in the schools as a mental health professional, and my mother and sister are educators. I have friends that are educators. And so I started off that school year just collaborating, communicating. They do a phone call of, “Hi, I’m the teacher,” and I introduced myself, and I immediately was like, “Hi, nice to meet you.
I want a meeting.” I was like, “I know you guys have to take time to set it up, but I’m just preemptively letting you know, being proactive. We’re gonna need a meeting.” My son was not diagnosed autistic yet, and neither was I. So it was just one of those, we’re seeing some perfectionism. He’d been in childcare since he was seven weeks old.
We’d seen transitions, moves, and things like that. And what my husband and I found was that even with all of our education, our professional background, there was this perception that our son was just choosing, quote-unquote, “to do things,” and that, if he just chose not to do those things, he would be fine.
And I think we would’ve maybe fed into that had he not done structured programming before. I think where some parents, especially us being military, my husband was active duty at the time. A lot of times the kids are home with mom, and so it’s like, “Oh, they’re not used to school and adjusting.”
In our case, he had been to three daycares already ’cause we’d moved three times. And we were like, “No, he’s kinda done this dance. That first week or two, it’s a little ‘Okay, we need to adjust.’ We collaborate, and he’s fine.” So we were like, “Something else is going on here.” And so we didn’t know the particulars, and even though I’m a document or it didn’t happen girl, we were still more verbal, like phone calls and pickup line conversations.
But I’d requested the things. I call ’em “the things,” in quotes. I was like, “Do we need a behavior plan? I don’t really know what that is, but do we need one?” “Do we need an IEP? I don’t really know what that is, but do we need one?” And it was like, “No.” And so it started with little write-ups. And then we came back from winter break, and then in two weeks he was suspended three times back to back.
So he’d get in the door, he’d be there less than an hour, get a phone call, he’s suspended. And so one of the things that was beneficial for us, though, during that time was that I was spending a lot of time with him. And so in spending a lot of time with him, I had the opportunity to have conversations with him and really see how things were from his perspective.
And I called a clinical psychologist, an educational psychologist that was Black, ’cause it was a predominantly white school and white area, and I called essentially crying and was like, “I’m a whole professional and I can’t help my kid. Please help me.” And they stepped in and immediately were like, “What do you think about autism?”
And I was like, “I’m confused.” And then I filled out the scales, and then I was like, “Oh, he’s like this, but so am I.” So I always like to add the caveat in of his teacher was amazing, and he actually went through three teachers because they all quit the district because the district was so horrible.
Tim Villegas: Really?
Destiny Huff: Yeah, that’s how rough it was.
Tim Villegas: That’s rough. Yeah, that’s rough.
Destiny Huff: But what they were also doing to a lot of our disabled learners was they were telling the parents like, “Oh, you could just homeschool ’em.” And then the moms were quitting their jobs and pulling them ’cause military life doesn’t always allow for you to keep working steadily, and dads are like, or partners are like, “I can’t keep having to go up to this school.”
And I remember the school psychologist going, “Didn’t you say mom works?” And they were like, “Yeah.” And she’s like, “So how is she gonna homeschool?” And I was like, “Yeah, so this is your game.” So that’s the short of it, of what was going on for us before we were like, we escalated it and we’re like, “Yeah, we gotta get some things done ’cause this is not gonna cut it.”
Tim Villegas: Yeah. So I wonder, just a little bit of a rabbit trail on what military families have to endure. I think that might be an insight that our audience is not aware of, right? What military families are up against when you have a learner who needs extra support in school. How did that play out with you? Did you have to move around additionally after Louisiana and figure out different schools, different states, all that stuff?
Destiny Huff: Yeah. Yeah, so that actually, my husband and I both subsequently changed our career path.
Tim Villegas: Wow, okay.
Destiny Huff: Yeah, it had that real-life impact for us. So as I stated before, he was active duty at the time, and he’s now reserve. So he’s an officer, and he needed rating time, and we were supposed to go overseas, and we ended up not being able to go overseas because you have to get certain clearances.
So in the military, they have EFMP. It’s called the Exceptional Family Member Program. You’re supposed to enroll in that if your learner has an IEP or if they have a disability. Once our son’s disability was identified, we then have to go through an extra layer to get approved. And he got approved medically, but educationally, because of the support that was being needed at the time, the educational system over there said, “We don’t feel we can support him.”
And so that delayed our move, delayed where we were going, and also subsequently delayed my husband’s rating time. And so then it was offered, “If you just stay here longer, you’ll get all your rating time, and you should be on track for your promotion.” And we went through so much trauma that my husband was like, “I will not do that to my family, much less myself.”
And so we did ultimately get to pick our next duty station, so where we were going next, but that did impact him being promoted. And that was when he made the decision that he was going to go from active to reserve. And so he’s a reservist now. And that is when I made the decision that for as long as he’s active, I need to be more readily available.
And so I was working outside of the home in mental health. I decided to start my advocacy business, and I decided to take my private practice, which was just a side hustle at the time. I decided to take it virtual and full time so that I could be available for my children and be available if I needed to go to the school, if I needed to support for any meetings or any things that came up.
So we both definitely pivoted our whole careers, and that is not uncommon for military families and spouses, spouses in particular, to put their careers on the back burner, change their careers entirely, or not have a career until their children are adults.
Tim Villegas: Well, thank you for sharing that, and thank you to your husband for his service. And also just, what a gift you have given with your platform.
And so I’d love to talk about this word neuroaffirming because it is everywhere. It’s on everything. So I would love for you to give our audience your definition. What does it mean to you?
Destiny Huff: Yeah. My friend Cheryl Poe, who is the founder of Advocating for Kids, Inc., said it best when she spoke at my summit. She said to her, neuroaffirming is to care. And I was like, oh my gosh, that is so powerful because I think we can get really bogged down into this child has this disability, and we need to fix them instead of support them. And so what neuroaffirming does is it essentially says, are we supporting them, and are we including them in the support we’re providing?
Because as adults, we tend to do that too. We tend to forget that these disabled children will become disabled adults, that they are people, and that they should be a part of the support we’re seeking for them. Now, that doesn’t disregard that we have more life experience. That doesn’t disregard that I’m telling you not to touch a hot stove. You shouldn’t touch a hot stove, right? But it does mean that they should be a part of it because it’s their life. So yeah, neuroaffirming has definitely become a buzzword. In my mind, it’s replaced, like inclusion and trauma informed, which were all buzzwords too at some point where they just get slapped on things.
And then when you actually ask people questions or what does that look like or what does that mean, they can’t even tell you.
Tim Villegas: Yeah. Do you think that’s why the major professional organizations like CEC or ASHA or any of the others, and I’m not saying those things to call out anybody, I’m just using them as examples. So don’t come at me, CEC and ASHA. But I’m just saying, professional organizations have not really leaned into neuroaffirming like some other people have.
Destiny Huff: Yeah. I absolutely think it has to do with kind of this misconception of research-based versus evidence-based, to be honest.
Tim Villegas: Okay. Interesting.
Destiny Huff: I think it really has to do with, for so long… And I always say it’s funny ’cause I’m an autistic and ADHD person, and so we’re always told about our black or white thinking, quote unquote. And I really think society thinks more black or white.
And what I mean by that is that we tend to go from one extreme to the other. And so for so many years, I think being in the mental health field and being in social and community services and then working with education professionals, there was a lot of just doing what feels right and natural, right?
So it was like, “I think this kid would benefit from this. We’re gonna do this. I think this approach would be good, so we’re gonna do this.” And then at some point somebody was like, “Can we do some research? Can we have some evidence? Can we put something behind this other than just what you think?”
And then we forgot that sometimes those interactions, those relationships, those instincts are beneficial.
And so I think, again, not to get on CEC national like you said, ’cause I’m a member of CEC, it became, “That’s the foundation of what we built this on. We have evidence and research to back why we’re saying the things we’re saying.” And along the way, that lived experience, that intuition, that relationship building just kinda got pushed to the side.
And so I think it’s just very hard when you build a platform on something to adjust without having that basis. And then we were for a little bit getting some research, so you can actually find some research about being neuroaffirming and what that looks like. But our current grant administration situation is preventing that access.
Tim Villegas: Oh my gosh, that’s a great point. The moment that we live in right now, it’s very difficult for that kind of work to happen. And then if you think about, okay, if there is a change even in the next two to four years, how long is that going to delay any sort of research that is published?
Because that takes a long time. So, to your point, yeah, I think it’s kinda easy to get real squishy about this works and that works and there’s no evidence for that, all that stuff.
I wanna ask about ABA, but I’m not trying to make anyone mad. I’m just trying to understand your perspective.
Because there is a lot of research, right, about applied behavior analysis. But there also is a lot of emerging research about neuroaffirming practices and brain science. And historically, how we’ve approached behavior has been through a behaviorist lens.
There’s a lot of stuff that’s informing that. I’m wondering from your perspective, is there a way that we can work within that framework, or is it time to just, the ABA baby is thrown out with the bathwater, and we just have to start over?
Destiny Huff: No. And I like how you approach it because I will say that I think that in the special education space, in the disability space, ABA is such a complicated topic.
And I post a lot of things, and I get sometimes some really heavy-handed, upset, angry responses, and I’m the type of person that I don’t care.
Tim Villegas: We do not care.
Destiny Huff: Do not care. And I say that because everything that I post is always very informational, first of all. I literally am like, “This is information.
This is giving perspectives.” The reason I say that is because as a parent of an autistic child, I remember receiving my child’s diagnosis and primary care immediately going, “Okay, 40 hours ABA, they can do speech. They can do this. They can do that.” And I remember thinking, “40 hours is a job. I work 40 hours every week.”
“What are we talking about?” And then on top of that, having the professional backing of being a mental health professional who works with children. I was like, I wouldn’t prescribe that for any child. It’s just too much. And so I think my different intersectionality, my different identities, the different layers.
So intersectionality means that we’re more than one thing, right? I’m a woman. I’m a professional. I’m a mother. I’m a wife. I’m Black. All these things play a role into how I view it. And so when it comes to it, I’ve seen a lot more neuroaffirming and affirming ABA providers, and you have some people that are like, “How is that even possible? You’re still going through a behaviorist lens.” And my thing is this: I think that there are problems with almost any type of treatment approach, intervention, modality. Not everything is gonna fit everyone. What I always say is, one, are we looking at trying to change that child, or are we looking at trying to support them?
Those are two very different things. The other thing is that what you mentioned, that lens. Looking through a compliance-based lens, which is often what behavior is, is very different from a neuroaffirming lens. And what I find when I have conversations with individuals that are RBTs or BCBAs working in ABA and trying to be neuroaffirming is that sometimes they still struggle with stepping away from the compliance-based lens.
“This is what they have to do, this is what my training is, and this is what they need to do.” And so I think that it’s not necessarily a throw it all out, but I do think that there are only surface level conversations being had because it’s getting a bad rap instead of really digging deeper and getting with individuals that can support what it looks like neuroaffirming.
And I say that because I did a training for an organization in the state last month, I think, and it was all RBTs and BCBAs. And with some of the information I was giving, they were like, “Oh my gosh, I didn’t even think of it that way,” because it’s just not in our training. I have all my degrees in psychology.
Deficit-based, compliance-based lenses is what we’re trained through.
And so you have to question your initial training to make any type of adjustment or change, and that’s really how I approach it.
Tim Villegas: Yeah. Same. As a former special education teacher, definitely, that was the program. You were trained in the deficit-based models, even medical, even though the programs I went to were much more talking about how do we change the environment rather than the child.
But yeah, when I was still working in schools, it was unique to have that perspective of, maybe we don’t have to think about compliance so much and creating little robots and stuff like that. But I think there’s not enough nuanced conversation about this topic out in the world. And it’s hard because, you know this as a personality, an influencer, someone on social media posting and trying to get conversations going. You post one thing, and it has a life of its own, right? There’s no nuance. There’s no conversation.
It’s just, “How could you say that? How could you think that?” All that stuff.
After the break, the question I hear a lot from you: schools need rules, so can we really step away from compliance? And then can a self-contained classroom really be neuroaffirming?
Let me take a minute to tell you about our other sponsor, Inclusive Schooling. Here is something we hear from educators all over the country: “We believe in inclusion, but what about students with challenging behavior? How do we include those learners, and how do we support everybody else in the room when so much of the day is going to behavior?”
That’s a fair question, so let me tell you about Behavior 360 from Inclusive Schooling. It starts from a completely different premise than most behavior training. Behavior is not just something to manage. It’s something to understand. Behavior 360 is grounded in neuroscience, in relationships, and in inclusive education, and it gives educators practical strategies they can use before, during, and after a hard moment, not theory and not another framework to put in a binder.
So if you’re a teacher, a coach, or a school leader looking for professional learning that makes classrooms safer and more inclusive at the same time, take a look at inclusiveschooling.com/mcie-behavior. We’ll put that link in the show notes. Again, inclusiveschooling.com/mcie-behavior.
So let me frame this idea of compliance, because I do know some people listening are like, “This all sounds great, Destiny, but we have to get things done in a school. We need people to follow rules in a school. Expectations. And if you do something, there may be consequences.” That’s a behaviorist way to think about it, but it’s also how we exist as a society, right?
So can we really truly get away from a behaviorist lens? And this is speaking as someone who definitely doesn’t want to look at things in a behaviorist lens, but sometimes you just have to. I don’t know.
Destiny Huff: No, but I think what you’re saying is valid because I get that question at IEP tables every week, month, day of the year. And I think it always goes back to what your perception is when you’re hearing what we’re discussing, right? I like to liken it to, I always bring it to gentle parenting. So many people mislabel gentle parenting. They’re really talking about permissive parenting, right? So permissive parenting is when you’re throwing the rules out the window. You’re not, you’re essentially not parenting really. You’re letting the inmates run the asylum, for lack of a better word. And people confuse that with gentle parenting.
Whereas gentle parenting is there’s natural consequences. I’m gonna tell you, “I wouldn’t jump on the couch. You might fall off like you’ve already done. And if you’re gonna keep doing it, the natural consequence when you fall off is ‘Oh, look, you fell off and you hurt yourself.’”
Tim Villegas: Yeah, natural consequence.
Destiny Huff: Yeah, absolutely. I still parented. I still was like, “Hey, let’s be safe.” But also I was like, “I guess we’re just gonna have to see what happens.” And a lot of people confuse that. And so I think also we have rose-colored glasses, right? About what it was like.
So many millennials, I’m a millennial, are in therapy. They have conversations about their feelings and their emotions. And I always say, each generation does the best they can. And so I always say, my parents’ generation was like, “I’m feeding you and giving you a home to live in. You’re welcome.” My parents were younger when they had me and my sister. It’s just the two of us. And so they were very much, “Hey, you can come to us and talk to us. We’re not maybe always having conversations about feelings and emotions, but you can come to us and talk to us.”
And so then I’ve subsequently become the parent that’s like, “No, let’s talk about those emotions. Let’s have those conversations, and let’s build some healthy coping skills,” right? And I’m hoping my kids will subsequently do the next thing of what that looks like. And it’s the same way with schools.
In my opinion, we’ve shifted, and nobody really recognizes the shift till we talk about the shift. So I remember when I was in school, I had an actual 30 minutes of lunch. Not get your stuff, go to the lunchroom, but I had an actual 30 minutes of lunch. I had an actual 30 minutes of recess, or, quote-unquote, “time with friends.”
So I got an hour break in my school day at school to just eat, relax, and socialize. Now teachers’ schedules are down to the minute. My kids would tell me, “Oh, Mommy, I go to lunch at 11:27.” I was like, “I’m sorry, what’s that?”
Tim Villegas: Oh, that’s so true.
Destiny Huff: You go to lunch at 11:27? And they’re like, “Yes.” And then subsequently, teachers will tell me, “Oh yeah, they have 30 minutes for lunch,” but that’s get your stuff, go to the lunchroom, get in line, get your lunch if you didn’t bring your lunch, go sit at the table, eat your lunch, clean up your lunch, get in line, go to recess. So I’m like, it’s not really 30 minutes.
We really got about 15 minutes in there, right? Same with my son’s kindergarten teacher. My kids are not in kindergarten anymore, but a few years ago she was like, “Yeah, I’m teaching first grade level curriculum in kindergarten now.” Which means kindergarten is no longer kindergarten.
It’s not play, it’s not socialization, it’s not relationship building. So in my opinion, when we start talking about they have to follow rules, yes, follow rules in the sense of safety, right? One of the things I always say when they’re like, “Okay, I need them to do this.” “Okay, why do you need them to do this?”
A lot of times why they need them to do it is, “Because my schedule is so packed and concise, I don’t have the time to consider what they need.” And it’s like, oh, okay. So now we have a systems issue, right? So I think a lot of times we’re just not digging deeper. My biggest thing is dig deeper, get curious.
We’re not having those conversations around the fact that the system is operating in a way that doesn’t allow for us to not be compliance-based. But then you do sometimes, depending on your program, your school, and your supervisor, have the opportunity to do that within your classroom. And I have seen educators that are like, “This is how I run my show.” And because of it, they have less, quote-unquote, “behavior issues.” They have less, quote-unquote, “concerns,” because they are actually being more accommodating, but we’re not calling it that. We’re not calling it accommodating. We’re not calling it supportive.
We’re not calling it neuroaffirming. We’re just saying, “Oh, they’re a good teacher,” which is great ’cause they clearly are, but it’s how you’re framing that view of things that I often find is the biggest issue. And sometimes teachers just don’t know they can do certain things. And when I bring it up and they’re like, “Oh my gosh, I could do that.”
Tim Villegas: Can you give me an example of something that you’ve told a teacher, like, “Hey, you can do this,” and the teacher’s like, “Wait, what?”
Destiny Huff: Yeah, so when we have assignments and rubrics and things like that. I’m gonna start with an example for my middle and high schoolers a lot of times, and maybe even fourth, fifth grade.
It’ll be like these are the standards they have to meet, right? So all teachers have their curriculum standards. They have to assess the learner by those standards. And just the fact that they don’t have to write a paper as long as they check these standards, some teachers are like, “Oh, they can do a PowerPoint, they can do a comic strip, they can do a recorded video, they can do a song, they can do a skit.”
And I’ve found that my ELA teachers and my history teachers, they’re like, “I’m already doing that.” A lot of them are doing that because a lot of them are like, “I don’t like writing papers,” or, “I don’t like doing this.” A lot of teachers that become teachers, and I’ve heard this from teachers, are like, “I might’ve been a student…” “I might’ve been this or that.” And so they became the teacher to give what they feel like they didn’t get, or ’cause they had a teacher that made them see it could be different, and they’re like, “I wish that students got this all the time.” So that’s a base example I like to give of where if they’re checking the boxes for what you’re assessing them on, it doesn’t have to be that they have to write this paper when you know that they love to do graphic design or they love to do PowerPoint presentations.
You can give them those alternatives and spice it up.
Tim Villegas: Oh, yeah. This is a little bit random, but you talked about PowerPoints and you… so my kids, I have three, 20, 17, and 14. And so my two oldest especially, they’ve gone to parties where it’s a PowerPoint party. Have you ever heard of this?
Destiny Huff: Yes. Yes, I have.
Tim Villegas: Yeah. And I’m like, “What?” It’s just funny to me. I guess I’m a late Gen X-er, so not exactly millennial. So yeah, that’s just not something I would’ve done. But it sounds awesome. You go and you just learn about stuff that people are interested in. That sounds great.
Destiny Huff: Yeah. And it’s so interesting because a lot of times what I do in IEP meetings I attend is, one, I’m gonna ask the teacher, “What are you seeing? How are you seeing it? Where are you seeing the barrier?” And sometimes teachers don’t get asked that. They get told how somebody else views it. They get told what they should do, but nobody actually asks them, so that’s a big thing that I like to do. And then I like to point out how we talk a lot about how we can’t individualize, even though teachers do a lot of individualizing.
You have small groups. In the beginning, you’re already assessing, where are my kids that are on target? Where are the kids that are below? Where are the kids that are above? And then you’re subsequently tailoring what you’re providing to that already. But the other side is I point out that I’ve never walked into a teacher’s classroom that looks the same as another teacher’s classroom.
Not ever. I don’t care if there’s a grade level theme. Your classroom is gonna look and be set up the way that makes you comfortable, and all we’re saying is, “How can I do that for my students?”
Tim Villegas: Yeah. Really great insights here. I’m hearing about asking learners and teachers what is working for them, and really creating partnerships between families, educators, and students to make an environment more inclusive, right? So really great insights. I’m hoping people are listening and watching and going, “This is really great stuff,” and check out your book and all that stuff.
I would like to talk about self-contained classrooms, if that’s okay. A lot of people that listen are interested in this placement question, right? Learners who have extensive support needs and who are by default put into a self-contained classroom or program for a particular disability.
So an autism program, intellectual disability program, behavior disorder program. And so what are your thoughts about, can those programs or classrooms be truly neuroaffirming if they are separate and segregated?
Destiny Huff: That’s a good question. And I think that they can be because sometimes the separation, in my opinion, is something that we can see the learner thrive in. I wanna elaborate on that statement because you’re absolutely correct in asking that question in that so many people… I think the biggest issue we’re having right now when it comes to special education and neuroaffirming and self-contained is that you have all these people that are like, “You’re just putting everyone in gen ed, and everyone doesn’t need to be there. And my kid that is not disabled is having the impact of these disabled kids,” which is a horrible way to think. And then you have other people that are like, “My kid…” And I’m seeing this with parents that are like, “My kid needs to be in special education. My kid needs to be separate from gen ed and separate from non-disabled learners, and I’m fine with them being in this setting, but I feel like the setting does not have the correct supports.”
And again, we go back to my view of societally, there’s so much black or white thinking. Why can we not look at the in between and meet in the middle? And what I mean by that is, one, if you are separating them solely on their disability category, no, I don’t think it’s neuroaffirming because you just made this assumption that all autistic learners, all intellectually disabled learners, all of them have the same support needs, and we just know that’s not true.
So that’s not neuroaffirming. On the other side, I have seen where, for example, my own son… They were like, “Oh, he could be in the lunchroom. There’s no reason why he can’t go to lunch instead of being in his self-contained classroom during lunch.” And this was last year. And he was like, “It’s too loud in there. It’s too loud, and I don’t like it. And I can hear them through my headphones, so I don’t wanna do it.” And I was like, that’s the way in which it’s neuroaffirming to have him eat in his self-contained classroom for lunch, because he’s like, “It’s too loud.”
And so it’s one of those things where, again, an assumption was being made of how his disability presents and what he needs, and he’s telling us, “Yeah, this is why.” He has a lot of sensory, and he’s like, “This is why that’s a no for me. And this is what I would like to do.” And so being neuroaffirming in that instance is listening to him, asking him, and then following through with that request. And I’ve had that happen with older learners where they’re like, “Yeah, I would like to do the resource class because there’s less students, it’s more individualized, I get this and that.”
I think it comes down to the support that’s being provided, and unfortunately, to the credit of individuals that are upset about gen ed access versus upset about self-contained, it has become a situation where the system is determining based on their perception and not the learner’s needs.
And so it’s become a situation where the learner may have to be a, quote-unquote, “behavior concern” to be in self-contained. Or the learner has to demonstrate certain cognitive abilities to be in gen ed or self-contained. And so then you do run into those issues. You have gen ed staff not even trained on how to support a disabled learner.
And so then there’s a lot of disruption, and there’s a lot of issues in gen ed. I really think that, in my opinion, a self-contained-type setting can be neuroaffirming. It can have supports. But it’s really about that perception and that training, and quite honestly, in my opinion, for the most part, neither staff is being trained adequately, not gen ed or special ed.
Tim Villegas: So there’s a couple layers here, right? There’s the law part of it, and IDEA assumes the general education setting, right? Just expanding on your own thoughts about neuroaffirming and adapting the environment to the child. Shouldn’t a general education setting adapt to a child? In theory, right? ’Cause in practice it doesn’t happen as often as we want. But wouldn’t the most neuroaffirming practice be to adapt that lunchroom for your child?
No, I’m trying to unpack this in a thoughtful way. Let’s say the lunchroom, and I’m just gonna use it ’cause you brought it up, not wanting to be in there. What if there was a decision that was made in that school to change something about the environment so that your son would enjoy actually going to lunch and being with peers, right?
So that would be a neuroaffirming practice. Now, it hasn’t, and he doesn’t wanna be in there. So we are not going to say, “We know better than you. We’re gonna honor the thing that you clearly want and you’re communicating,” right?
So I guess I’m trying to understand that. I think that we should be trying to educate and equip educators and school districts to adapt their environments so that every learner does belong in a general education setting. And there are gonna be these very, very rare instances where we’re going to have to set up an environment or set up supports for a child that may be outside, and the law actually outlines that very specifically. So in my opinion, I feel like schools, and this is not a dig, “You should be doing all of this.” I think everyone’s super overwhelmed, right? But the system is set up in a way that it’s easier to be like, “We don’t have time to adapt, but we do have a program. We have a program.” And so from our perspective at MCIE, and from what we’ve been advocating for at the educator and system level, it’s possible if we go through systems change and we actually change how we run schools and how we support learners.
Destiny Huff: 100%. And I did note this was last year, and this year he is in the lunchroom.
Tim Villegas: Hey, okay.
Destiny Huff: Because they did make adjustments.
Tim Villegas: Look at that.
Destiny Huff: Because they did feel like, yeah, it’s loud. And they were like, “No, that’s a valid problem.” And we were like, we could see that being a barrier to him being in that setting.
But what you’re speaking to is very valid. Going back to mental health, that magic wand question where we’re like, if you could wave a magic wand, what would you change? What would be different? 110%, every environment would be adjusted to support the learner.
In my opinion, educational environments don’t even support non-disabled learners at this point. They don’t even support the educators that are in the environment. But you’re correct. In that ideal world, the neuroaffirming would be, and I have come across school systems and programs that are willing to learn and make the adjustment.
And it’s amazing once they make those adjustments, how they’re like, “We’re gonna do this for everyone.” Even my son’s old school, when we were helping him learn emotions and things like that, and this was where we called this his year of really re-loving school and realizing that school loved him, after everything that had happened in Louisiana.
So this is a few years ago now. I came up with a system of helping him learn emotions and navigate them, and I used this Ninja book series. So there’s this Ninja book series, and it has these different emotions, and that’s what I was using ’cause he was five, and it was for ages five to eight.
And so I was like, “Okay, let’s talk about this emotion and ask these questions and do this.” And they actually adopted the whole curriculum that came with it because they saw how impactful it was for him. And I was going around the school one day, and I saw a poster, and I was like, “What is this?”
And they were like, “Yeah, we got that from you.” So it’s being open and responsive to that. And I think once you can see the benefit, right? But you also have to not be taxed in the moment. We know that’s what school systems are going through. They’re taxed, stretched, and so it’s hard to receive information.
But also I’ve seen some where they’re so taxed and stressed that they’re like, “Whatever’s gonna work. You tell us, we’re gonna give it a roll, and we’ll see what happens.” But yeah, you’re right. It would be adjusting that environment. It would be creating that. And I think it’s also multifaceted and multilayered, right?
In that you have some learners that, and I’ve had this with some of my high schoolers, where they don’t wanna eat in the lunchroom because it’s just too many people. So it’s certain things where it’s for them, having the ability to go to a smaller place does benefit.
But again, for us to know that, we have to dig deeper, we have to get curious, we have to ask questions. And sometimes we stop there and we just go, “This is why they don’t wanna do it, and so this is what we’re gonna do.” And then when it doesn’t work, we’re like, “I don’t know why it’s not working.”
And I’m like, “Maybe ’cause we didn’t ask anybody anything. We just made an assumption.”
Tim Villegas: Yeah, there’s so many things to take away from this conversation, so I think this is great. And I hope everyone listening and watching, if you have more questions, please reach out to Dr. Destiny Huff or myself, and we’d love to engage with you in conversation, ’cause it sounds like you like conversation. All right, before we get to our last segment, any last thoughts, anything you wanna highlight to our audience of educators, advocates, and families?
Destiny Huff: Yeah, communication, collaboration, and documentation. That’s the best way. And you can’t do that if you’re defensive, and I think that’s the piece I’m always working through with educators I talk to, that are friends or family. I’m always working through that defensiveness and going, “Okay, let me give you a parent’s perspective of why a parent might say that.”
And typically it doesn’t have anything to do with the other adult. And same with parents. They’ll be like, “I don’t understand why the teacher would ask that or why they would say that like that,” or… And I’m like, “I think they’re genuinely asking. They really wanna know.” But it’s hard when you’ve had so much thrown at you. And so that’s why I say communication, collaboration, and documentation. And then I always say, don’t ever forget that no matter how much professional experience you have, no matter if you’ve been doing this for 20 years, the parent is the only consistent member for that child at every IEP table and IEP meeting.
And so they are bringing knowledge and years that you just don’t have. And so don’t forget that when you’re saying, “This’ll work,” and they’re like, “That’s been tried and it hasn’t worked,” you gotta add a little bit more to it for why it’s gonna work this time.
Tim Villegas: Yeah. Important things to remember. So thank you for that.
Okay, so our last segment is a micro role-playing game, and this is brand new for season 14 of Think Inclusive. And so really, Destiny, all we’re doing is we’re going to tell a story together, okay? We’re gonna co-create a story. Have you ever done any role-playing, Dungeons & Dragons, anything like that?
Destiny Huff: Some education stuff that I’ve done in my classes, but never Dungeons & Dragons, no.
Tim Villegas: Okay. This isn’t quite Dungeons & Dragons. This is called Awake Among the Stars. So I will be the narrator of this story, and then I’m gonna ask you questions, and then you can make things up on the spot, and there’s no right answer. However your imagination takes you, that’s the way that it is, and then we play off of each other, and we’ll do it for five or 10 minutes and that’s it. What I have, since you don’t have it, is a six-sided die and a pack of playing cards, and that adds the element of randomness to our story. Okay? And so what I’d like for you to do is, I’m gonna have you close your eyes. I’m gonna read a narration, and then I’m going to roll, and that will determine who your character is. Okay?
Destiny Huff: Okay.
Tim Villegas: All right. It’s gonna be great. It’s gonna be great. All right. Close your eyes, and then when I count down from three, I will start reading. So three, two, one. You wake up gasping, cold, floating in a dim metal room. Your head is pounding, and your memory is syrup. You’ve got classic hibernation sickness.
A soft chime, you hear in the corner of the room, and it’s your ship’s computer, Cora. And your ship’s computer says, “Good morning. You’ve been asleep for a very long time. We are in orbit above an uncharted planet. Also, minor note, our teleporter is running on reserve power, so please explore responsibly.”
Through the porthole of the ship, you see a large spinning planet beneath you, one that you don’t recognize. So first thing is first, I’m gonna roll the die, and we’ll get your character. Okay, you ready? Here we go. You are six. You are Professor Mittens. You are a house cat with three doctorates, and your mission or motivation is scientific glory and somewhere to take a nap. Okay? So Professor Mittens, we have to figure out where you’re going on your exploring trip. Okay, so I am going to roll the die one more time. Here we go, and it’s a four. And oh, Professor Mittens, you’re going to the ocean world. I don’t know how cats like water, but I don’t think they like water. But listen, the dice tells us where we’re going.
Destiny Huff: Okay.
Tim Villegas: Tell you what. What I’m gonna do is, Professor Mittens is going to go down on a kind of a platform. Professor Mittens, you’re not going to immediately get wet, okay? All of a sudden, the room is filled with light, and you are suddenly transported like that down to the ocean world.
And so just an explanation about the ocean world. It’s a planet covered with water, right? But the water is only about three or four feet deep. So there’s no waves. It’s just kind of water, and there’s lots of islands all over the place. Some look like they have buildings. Some don’t. And you’re not really sure. But Professor Mittens, you are on a little hovering platform, and you’ve got a really small backpack next to you that has stuff in it. It’s up to you if you wanna look to see what’s in the backpack. And you are looking around, and so one of the first things you have to do is you have to decide what you wanna do now that you’re on the ocean world, which means you have to pick a card.
So one, two, or three?
Destiny Huff: Two.
Tim Villegas: Two. Okay. You pick the queen of hearts. So then I go to my storybook, and I look at queen of hearts and see what you are doing. Where are my hearts? Oh, here we go. Okay. So you’re on your hoverboard and you are scooting around, and all of a sudden… So the water is crystal clear, like you are in the Gulf of, I’m gonna say, Mexico. And so when you look down, the water goes down actually really deep in this part, and there’s lots of different statues. You’re not exactly sure ’cause you can only see so much, but there’s probably seven, eight or nine statues in this kind of big hole, under a shelf, and you’re hovering over it with your hoverboard.
So what do you wanna do?
Destiny Huff: I wanna go see the statues.
Tim Villegas: Okay. So I think you should look in your backpack.
Destiny Huff: Okay.
Tim Villegas: Okay. So you open your backpack, and what do you see that could help you…
Destiny Huff: Go see the statues?
Tim Villegas: Explore these statues, yeah.
Destiny Huff: Yeah. Wait, I’m on a hoverboard.
Tim Villegas: You’re on a hoverboard.
Destiny Huff: I’m not getting wet?
Tim Villegas: You’re not getting wet, so is there anything in your backpack that could help you not get wet and dive into the water?
Destiny Huff: An oxygen mask?
Tim Villegas: Okay. That covers your entire body, I’m guessing? Or just your head?
Destiny Huff: I’m thinking scuba gear. I need scuba gear.
Tim Villegas: Scuba gear. Okay.
Destiny Huff: With an oxygen tank.
Tim Villegas: So you reach into your backpack and you find perfectly suited scuba gear for Professor Mittens, the house cat with three doctorates, okay? So then you put your oxygen mask on and you take a dive off of the hoverboard, and now you are deep, deep into this little cavern with all of these statues. And you go up to a statue, and you are looking at it, and what do you see? What does the statue look like?
Destiny Huff: The statue looks like a founder of the Water World.
Tim Villegas: Ah. So you go up to the statue, and there’s a big plaque on the front of this founder of Water World. And what does it say?
Destiny Huff: It says, “In honor of Lord Waters.”
Tim Villegas: In honor of Lord Waters, exactly. That’s exactly what it says. All right. So in your little oxygen mask, you have a speaker that your ship’s computer can talk to you with. And so Cora says, “Professor Mittens, we are running out of power. You can only do one more thing before I have to teleport you back to the ship. So you need to pick one or two,” and we will pick a card.
Destiny Huff: I need to pick a card?
Tim Villegas: Yeah, one or two.
Destiny Huff: One.
Tim Villegas: One. All right. So one is nine of diamonds. So you’re in the cavern. You are…
Siri (Tim’s phone): The only option I found is Natural Bridge Caverns on Natural Bridge Caverns Road in San Antonio, about 162 miles to your west, and it gets 100% positive ratings. Do you want that one?
Tim Villegas: No.
Siri (Tim’s phone): Looks like that’s it.
Tim Villegas: I’m not gonna say what it is because it’s gonna do it. My phone is connected, that’s why. Okay. The nine of diamonds. Okay, so here’s what happens. You’re not gonna believe this. So you are looking at this statue. And all of a sudden, all of these seven…
Let’s say there’s seven statues. All of these seven statues start to come to life. Okay? And they all start moving their arms up and turning their heads very, very slowly, very creepily, right? And you see them, and they’re actually getting off of their platforms, and they’re starting to swim very slowly all around you.
And you are just looking. So what do you wanna do? What do you wanna do about that?
Destiny Huff: I wanna leave.
Tim Villegas: All right, so then, it’s perfect timing because Cora says, “Professor Mittens, we are almost out of power. I’m gonna take you back to the ship.” Okay, so all of a sudden you are enveloped in this light, and you are back on the ship, and you are actually just a little bit wet because of your wetsuit. But you take off your wetsuit and, fortunately, there’s a big air dryer that dries you instantly, and you’re totally fine. Okay. And so Cora says, “I’m so glad you’re back on the ship. You’re the first one that has ever explored this water world, so you get to name this world. What do you wanna name it?”
Destiny Huff: I don’t have anything. I would just name it Aquaworld.
Tim Villegas: Aquaworld, there you go. That’s perfect. And then you are entering a log about Aquaworld. And so what’s one thing that you will remember about Aquaworld?
Destiny Huff: That if you dive deep, the statues will come to life.
Tim Villegas: There you go. Okay. I like it. And so Cora says, “Thank you for your log. Time to go back to sleep, and we’re gonna get you to another planet. But that’s for next time. And thank you for playing Awake Among the Stars.”
Ah. Did you like that? Was that fun? That was fun for me.
Destiny Huff: That was funny. And my immediate thought was that they were like, “You weren’t supposed to be here,” and that’s why they came alive. They’re like, “Who are you, and what are you doing here?” And so I was like, “Let me get outta here because you’re not wrong. I came in your space.”
Tim Villegas: That’s true. That’s such a lesson, right? Such a lesson. Yeah, and some mysteries will just remain mysteries. So thank you, Dr. Destiny Huff, for being on the Think Inclusive podcast. We really appreciate it.
Destiny Huff: Yes, thank you for having me.
Tim Villegas: That was Dr. Destiny Huff. Here’s what I’m taking with me. First, her question, are we trying to change this child or support them? Those are two different things, and the answer usually shows up in the lens we’re using. Second, when a teacher says, “I need them to do this,” Destiny asks why. A lot of the time, the honest answer is that the schedule is packed down to the minute, and that’s not a child problem.
That’s a systems problem. And third, the lunchroom. Last year, her son ate in his classroom because the cafeteria was too loud. This year, he’s in the lunchroom because the school listened and changed the environment. One practical step for educators, think thoughtfully about the environment. Are we asking the child to change, or are we thinking about how we can change the environment so the child can be authentically included and experience belonging?
We’ll link Destiny’s book, Neuroaffirming Advocacy, and the Affirming Village podcast in the show notes. Share this episode with a colleague who’s building inclusive schools. Rate and review us on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, and follow Think Inclusive wherever you get your podcasts.
If you have something to share, please email me at tvillegas@mcie.org. Now, let’s roll the credits. Think Inclusive is brought to you by me, Tim Villegas. This show is a proud production of the Maryland Coalition for Inclusive Education. Writing help from Claude, editing by Rey from Internet, scheduling and extra production help from Jill Wagoner.
Our original music is by Miles Kredich, with extra vibes from Melod.ie. Awake Among the Stars is adapted from Alone Among the Stars by Takuma Okada. You can find the original role-playing game at the link in our show notes. Big thanks to our sponsors, IXL and Inclusive Schooling. Visit ixl.com/inclusive and inclusiveschooling.com/mcie-behavior.
If you’ve made it this far, you’re officially part of the Think Inclusive inclusion crew. Want to help us keep the needle moving for inclusion? Head to mcie.org and click the Donate button. Give $25, $55, $100, or even $1,000. It helps us keep partnering with schools and districts to move inclusive practices forward and support educators doing the work.
Find us on the socials almost everywhere @thinkinclusive. Thanks for hanging out, and remember, inclusion always works.
Key Takeaways
- Neuroaffirming starts with one question: change or support? Destiny says most of what schools do leans toward changing the child, and the lens you use decides which one you end up doing.
- The rule is often about the schedule, not the student. When she asks why a teacher needs a student to comply, the honest answer is often a day packed down to the minute.
- Lunch and recess have shrunk. “30 minutes for lunch” includes lining up, getting food, and cleaning up, which leaves about 15 minutes to eat and talk.
- Keep the standard, change the format. Students can show the same learning through a slide deck, comic strip, video, song, or skit.
- Ask the teacher what they are seeing. In IEP meetings Destiny asks teachers where the barrier is, because they rarely get asked.
- Sorting by disability category is not neuroaffirming. It assumes every autistic or intellectually disabled student has the same support needs.
- Change the room, not the kid. Her son moved from eating in his classroom to eating in the lunchroom after the school made adjustments for noise.
- The parent is the only constant at the IEP table. Families bring years of knowledge no one else in the room has, so explain why something will work this time.
Resources
- Destiny Huff Consulting
- Neuroaffirming Advocacy: A Parent and Educator Guide to Special Education
- The Affirming Village Podcast with Dr. Destiny Huff and Lisa Baskin Wright
- Destiny on Instagram
- Alone Among the Stars by Takuma Okada
Sponsors
- IXL, the all-in-one K-12 platform that adapts to each student
- Behavior 360 from Inclusive Schooling, professional learning that treats behavior as something to understand rather than manage
